BALLARD, HARVEY E.1*, GAR ROTHWELL1, and RUTH STOCKEY2. 1Department of Environmental and Plant Biology, Ohio University, Athens OH 45701 USA; 2Department of Biological Sciences, University of Alberta, Edmonton AB T6G2E9 Canada. - Reassessing relationships among aroids and duckweeds.
Although aroids (Araceae) and duckweeds (Lemnaceae) are widely
regarded as having close systematic relationships, the relative
phylogenetic positions of the families remain equivocal. While some
data sets (i.e., morphology including fossils and rbcL
sequences) suggest that Pistia is sister to the Lemnaceae,
other data sets (i.e., chloroplast restriction sites) remove these to
separate clades within the Araceae. We are testing these competing
hypotheses using sequences from the trnL-F spacer region of the
chloroplast genome. Included in the analysis are 21 aroid genera
including Pistia, and five genera of Lemnaceae (including the
segregate genus Landoltia). Aponogeton is used to root
the tree. Approximately 520 aligned base pairs yield maximum parsimony
trees nearly identical to those derived from restriction site data.
Pistia and the Lemnaceae are placed in two separate and well
supported clades, suggesting at least two independent origins of the
floating aquatic growth form within the aroid clade. Within the
Lemnaceae there is only partial support for the paradigm of sequential
morphological reduction, given that Wolffia is sister to
Wolffiella+Lemna sensu stricto. Interestingly, single
rooted fronds assigned to Lemna minuscula are genetically
identical to Landoltia, and these are sister to the
(Wolffia (Wolffiella+Lemna)) clade. As in the
results of the restriction site analysis, pantropical Pistia is
placed with Colocasia and Typhonium of southeastern
Asia, indicative of Old World affinities. The duckweeds show
dramatically greater rates of nucleotide substitutions and
insertion/deletion events relative to the other ingroup taxa.
Morphological reduction within the duckweeds thus appears to correlate
with accelerated chloroplast genome evolution.
Key words: Araceae, cladistic relationships, Lemnaceae, trnL-F