LES, DONALD H.1*, DANIEL J. CRAWFORD2, REBECCA T. KIMBALL3, MICHAEL L. MOODY1, and ELIAS LANDOLT4. 1University of Connecticut, Department of Ecology & Evolutionary Biology, Storrs, CT 06269-3043; 2University of Kansas, Department of Ecology & Evolutionary Biology, Lawrence, KS 66045; 3University of Florida, Department of Zoology, Gainesville, FL 32611-8525; 4Geobotanisches Institut ETH, Zürichbergstrasse 38, CH-8044, Zürich, Switzerland. - Biogeography of cosmopolitan hydrophytes: a molecular appraisal of intercontinental disjunctions.
Many aquatic vascular plants show cosmopolitan geographical
distributions at taxonomic levels ranging from family to species. The
unusually widespread distributions of hydrophytes have intrigued
botanists since De Candolle, who thought the pattern arose by multiple
convergent origins. However, Darwin believed that the wide
distribution of hydrophytes was due to long-distance avian dispersal,
an explanation that continues to hold favor. Human introductions over
long distances are also possible, especially in Lemnaceae where the
minute plants are often transported with aquarium stock. We suggest
that the great age of many aquatic families coupled with the effects
of continental drift (its phytogeographical implications elucidated
relatively recently), should also be considered as possible factors
involved in the genesis of cosmopolitan hydrophyte distributions.
Examples of both temperate and tropical intercontinental disjunctions
are evident in the aquatic families Aponogetonaceae, Callitrichaceae,
Ceratophyllaceae, Haloragaceae, Hydrocharitaceae, Lemnaceae,
Nymphaeaceae and Podostemaceae. Analogous interoceanic disjunctions
also occur in marine angiosperm (seagrass) families such as
Cymodoceaceae, Posidoniaceae and Zosteraceae. We evaluated
transoceanic disjunctions in cosmopolitan hydrophytes using molecular
data to estimate divergence times for various aquatic taxa. Unlike
oceanic islands which typically indicate recent plant colonization via
long-distance dispersal, the estimated divergence times for disjunct
aquatic plants are much more ancient in comparison. Our findings
indicate that disjunctions in several aquatic groups are consistent
with phytogeographical hypotheses invoking continental drift, and
dismiss the possibility of recent long-distance dispersal by birds or
humans. Phylogenetic data of some cosmopolitan hydrophytes also
indicate phytogeographical patterns corresponding to age-area models.
However, there are several instances (mainly in Lemnaceae) where
widespread aquatic species exhibit much less molecular diversity than
expected, where recent secondary dispersal is highly unlikely, but
cannot be ruled out.
Key words: angiosperms, aquatic plants, molecular clock, phytogeography